**The most recent version of this article is available at http://horizon.unc.edu/ts/default.asp?show=article&id=903 **
Go to critical reviews
Introduction
Electronic
documents allow faculty to distribute and display course materials, provide
sample documents and reference materials, let students submit documents
electronically, and archive student work.
For
example, sample documents are useful in writing classes for the following:
Models of both good and
bad writing techniques
Samples of types of
technical documents
Samples of page design
and layout
Textbooks
are usually limited in the types of documents they provide. Documents are often
not up-to-date. In addition, lengthy documents, such as manuals, are not
incorporated.
In
addition, there are copyright and cost issues involved in printing, duplicating,
and distributing handouts to use in class. Using custom printed workbooks
requires extensive lead-time: getting permissions and submitting materials to a
printing service.
The
Internet has made available of a limitless supply of documents from all types of
organizations, thus transforming the types of resources available to faculty and
students. Adobe Acrobat PDF (Portable Document Format) documents from the Web
can be used as an effective teaching tool in the classroom, residence hall,
home, or wherever students access the Internet. PDF files are also ideal ways to
distribute materials in distance learning courses. A wide variety of types of
documents from numerous organizations are available. They can provide resource
material and examples. Best of all, they are free to obtain and to distribute
and require only Acrobat Reader.
Acrobat
Primer
Adobe
Acrobat is a suite of software programs used for electronic publishing. With
Adobe Acrobat PDF files can be published and distributed anywhere, such as e-mail attachments, Web sites, CD-ROM, and intranets. When you buy Acrobat, you
get Acrobat Reader, Acrobat, Distiller, and Catalog.
Acrobat
Reader software lets
you view, navigate through, and print PDF files regardless of the computer,
monitor, or software version. You may make and distribute unlimited copies of
the Acrobat Reader software. Reader is available to anyone to as a free
download. This is really the only
“negative” of PDF files. Students must have Reader and a computer to view
PDF files.
Acrobat
has all the capabilities of Reader and more. It allows you to view, create, and
modify PDF files by adding hyperlinks, bookmarks, thumbnails, multimedia (such
as movies and sounds), and annotations. It also allows you to create PDF files
from Web sites for viewing offline.
Distiller
is a driver that converts PostScript files to PDF. It has many options for
output, such as the amount of compression, color quality, embedding fonts, and
image resolution.
Catalog
lets you create a full-text index of your PDF documents or document
collections. This full-text index is a searchable database of all the text in a
document or set of documents
Faculty
and students can also create their own materials and even download Web sites
using the suite of programs that comes when you purchase Acrobat. Academic
pricing for Acrobat 4.05, the current version, is $99 for an individual copy. A
site license price will vary, depending upon campus agreements. For more
information, see Adobe’s
Education Site.
Benefits
Adobe
Acrobat documents have many benefits over HTML documents and are excellent tools
to use in classes for the following reasons:
Preserved Format: One
of the greatest benefits of PDF over HTML is the ability of Acrobat to preserve
a document’s appearance, including fonts. The document can be created in just
about any type of application, then converted to PDF.
The formatting is preserved, including color, fonts, mathematical
equations, etc. You can also create forms that preserve their format, unlike
HTML forms, which have limited design possibilities. Acrobat also lets
you view PostScript documents on-screen. This provides easy access to
information that currently exists in PostScript format, such as newsletters and
brochures.
Document Type: PDF files may be generated from almost any
kind of file: word processors, page layout programs databases and spreadsheets..
You can also scan documents or images. Acrobat supports images such as BMP, GIF,
JPEG, PCX, PICT, PNG, or TIFF file formats. The graphics are maintained as part
of the document, unlike Web pages.
Platform
Independence: Acrobat is
platform-independent; Acrobat Reader is available for Windows, Mac, and UNIX.
Thus faculty can use such documents in any computer lab, or students can view
documents at home.
Internet and Browser
Independence: Students do
not necessarily need to be connected to the Internet or have a particular
browser to view PDF files. They only need Acrobat Reader.
File Size and
Flexibility: Acrobat
documents are usually smaller than other file formats because PDF uses
compression. If a file is too large, the document can be split into separate
parts for downloading. The files are easier to save and keep for later viewing
than HTML documents. Web pages with frames are especially difficult to save.
Enhancements:
Using Acrobat, you can add hypertext links, buttons, and Internet links.
Bookmarks and thumbnails (miniatures of each page) also allow readers to
navigate the document. For example,
bookmarks, which appear on the left side of the page, can show the hierarchical
outline of the document.
Multimedia:
Acrobat documents can contain multimedia (movies and sound). Thus documents can
be more interactive, and you can add commentary.
Security: You can lock a document with password protection,
set defaults for page size and the tools visible, and add digital signatures.
Collaboration: If
students or colleagues have Acrobat and proper permission, they can add
annotations to the document. Acrobat also contains highlighting and rubber stamp
tools. These collaboration tools can be used to edit files in groups. Faculty
can also use this feature to grade/comment on student work.
Reader Tools: Using
Acrobat Reader, students can copy and paste text and graphics to use in other
applications. The Find feature allows readers to search for keywords.
Electronic
Distribution: PDF files can
be distributed electronically: by e-mail, CD-ROM, disk, network, or the Web.
Because PDF files are an excellent way to distribute teaching materials
electronically, they can be used to support distance learning courses. Students
can simply download the PDF file. PDF files also print correctly on any
printing device. Because Acrobat
Reader is free, faculty do not have to incur duplicating costs
Important Technology:
Adobe Acrobat publishing is used in many organizations. Thus faculty can also
use PDF documents as an opportunity to teach students about this technology.
Resource Material:
PDF files can provide extra resources that can be used to supplement textbooks.
Literally thousands of types of documents from a wide variety of organizations
are available on the Web and ftp sites in Acrobat format rather than as regular
html documents. Examples of the types of documents available include the
following:
Books
Brochures
Career information
Flowcharts
Forms
Government publications
Because
PDF is the standard for most government agencies and organizations, a wealth of
technical documents is available.
Graphics
Handbooks
Manuals
Maps
Newsletters
Plans
For
example, some schools and universities publish their technology plans in PDF
format.
Posters
See
an example
of the use of multimedia study posters in biology courses.
Procedures
Many
organizations, government agencies, and businesses post their procedures online.
Proposals
One
of the best sources of proposal resources is the National Science Foundation
site.
Puzzles, crafts,
activities, and games
Quick references
Reference
Reference
materials such as the Periodic Table are available in PDF format.
Reports
Resumes
Slideshows
Textbooks
Textbook publishers, such as DDC,
often make sample chapters in PDF format available for free.
Troubleshooting
documents
Tutorials
For
example, entire 200+page tutorials on FrontPage, HTML, and other software are
available from Training Tools.
White papers
There
are several quick ways to find PDF files to use in class:
·
Use the advanced
(Boolean) search feature found in search engines such as go.com. Type the name
of the type of document you want, such as “procedures” or “newsletters.”
Also search for the keywords “PDF” or “Acrobat.”
·
Go to the Adobe
Acrobat home page to find PDF files about Acrobat, tutorials in PDF format,
and case studies.
·
Visit
Electronic Publishing Research Group:
PDF Corner. It includes links
to numerous PDF pages featuring everything from PDF games to PDF guides.
·
Visit PDFzone.com
(figure 1)
to view a showcase and archive of good uses and users of PDF documents. This
site contains samples from Arts and Humanities, Business and Economy, Computers
and Internet, Education,
Entertainment, Government, Health, News and Media, Recreation and Sports,
Reference, Science, and Society and Culture.
Once
you find a PDF document on a Web site, here are a few tips:
·
To view the
document, left-click the link to the PDF file.
If you are using a newer version of Netscape or Internet Explorer, the
file will open Reader within your browser window. You can click the disk icon to
save it.
·
To download the
file without viewing it, right-click the link to the file. A popup menu
will appear in Netscape and Internet Explorer. You can then save the file to
view later and continue to browse the Web as the file downloads.
Using Text and Graphics From PDF Files
You
can use text and graphics from PDF files in other applications.
·
Use the Text Select
Tool
to
highlight the text.
Click the triangle on the Text Select Tool to access the other selection tools.
·
Use the Column Select
Tool
to select single columns of text.
·
Use the Table/Formatted
Text Select Tool
to
select tables.
·
Use the Graphics
Select Tool
to
draw a box around the graphic (or portion) you want to use.
After
you have copied text or a graphic, paste it into another application, such as
PowerPoint.
Creating
Your Own Acrobat Documents
Besides
using existing PDF documents, faculty and students can create and distribute
their own materials. One of the most useful features of Acrobat 4 is the ability
to download Web sites.
Creating Simple PDF Files
Faculty
can create PDF documents to distribute syllabi, presentations, and course notes.
If you use Microsoft Office, Acrobat installs a PDF Writer icon
in
the application. Clicking the icon launches PDFWriter, which creates a PDF file.
PDFWriter is less powerful than Acrobat Distiller but adequate for simple
documents. You do have several
output options. For example, headings you have used in Word can be converted
automatically to bookmarks in the PDF document.
If
you do not want to enhance the document in any way, it’s that simple to create
a PDF file.
Enhancing PDF Documents
If
you want to enhance your documents, Acrobat has several tools that are simple to
use. You can do some basic text editing, insert and delete pages, and create
bookmarks and thumbnails that can be used for navigation.
As the dialog box in figure
2 shows, you can
also set defaults on how the way the document and toolbars will appear when
opened.
You can also enhance the
document by adding links. You simply use the Link Tool
to
draw a box around an area. The resulting dialog box, shown in figure
3, allows you to
select the action that results when the link is clicked. The link may jump to
another location, Web address, or play a multimedia file.
Creating PDF Files From Image Collections and Scanned Documents
You
can also convert an entire image collection to PDF and display one image at a
time like a slideshow. Scanned documents can also be converted directly to PDF
format.
Creating
Presentations
You
can convert PowerPoint slideshows to PDF format and display them full screen
like any presentation. You can set a background color, hide the toolbars, and
set other options. Because Acrobat
Reader lets you change the magnification level, you can enlarge the document so
students can easily view it.
Students
can submit their assignments in PDF format, thus saving printing costs. Faculty
can then keep an electronic archive of sample student work. Because PDF files
are relatively small, they are ideal to send as e-mail attachments. Students can
also convert their class work to an electronic portfolio and distribute their
resumes on CD-ROM or a Web site.
Even
more important, you can download Web sites for off line viewing during class.
Using this technique, you can convert useful Web resources to PDF files. For
example, you can also save useful reference materials, such as grammar and
writing guidelines or tutorials. This feature is also useful in courses that use
Web sites as examples. Students can view the sites without having Internet
access and becoming distracted by surfing other sites. For example, figure
4 shows a browser tutorial saved in Adobe Acrobat. It is a 33-page
document, and all the original links work if the destination page has been
downloaded.
As
the dialog box in figure
5 shows, saving a Web site in PDF is simple. You have to
be careful, however, not to download an entire site, which can potentially be
quite large and take hours.
After
you specify the Web address, you specify how many “levels” of the site you
want to download. Each time you click a link on the page you’ve downloaded,
the destination of the link downloads. You continue this process until you’ve
downloaded and saved all the pages you want.
There
are a variety of ways you can use the PDF files you create outside or during
class. You can distribute PDF files in the following ways:
·
CD-ROM
·
network drives
·
your Web site
·
online class reserves
through the campus library
·
e-mail
You can use the files during class by having students view documents at their own computers. If you are in a regular classroom, you can also project samples and enlarge them on a screen.
Summary
Adobe
Acrobat PDF documents are an easy, effective, and inexpensive way to distribute
examples, reference materials, and assignments. A collection of such materials
provides students with an electronic “library” of real examples. In
addition, students can use the tutorials, career information, and reference
materials as inexpensive learning resources.
The following sites provide more information about PDF and samples.
Critic AF
As an article, it sort of reads like the back of the box, and it's also old news to boot Adobe has some great tools, but they have been used for several years now, and I can remember first using .pdf for distance classes in '97. This isn't meant to minimize the importance of the discovery for the author, but I kind of think most TS readers would be used to .pdf.
So my vote is for no.
Critic QQ
Publish with major revisions
This reads like the instructions and promotional blurb on the side of the box, plus an instruction sheet inside. The information on Acrobat itself and how to use it is readily available with the software and doesn't need to be laid out in the article. The title is "Using PDF in the Classroom," but the article doesn't follow the title. It's more of a handout for a computer lab. It should be rewritten to tell more about possible problems, first person experiences, and actual classroom uses. The Resource Material section doesn't add anything and should be eliminated or rewritten in prose rather than a list.
Critic L
The biggest problem I have with this article is that I
feel I am reading an ad rather than an article. Perhaps the writing style
has something to do with this. The other problem is that Acrobat software has
been around for quite a while now and PDF files are widely used online. I am
not sure how much new information is being put forth here to justify the
extensive discussion of a piece of commonly known software. I found the
article laid out its points clearly, made helpful suggestions, and was a very
useful guide, but this still seems more like a handout than a discussion on
the importance or utilization of the technology in a given setting.
Perhaps part of the discussion could focus on
alternatives to PDF files and why they are or are not viable. Perhaps
there could be more discussion of how the author has used or seen the software
used in a particular class. What about drawbacks to using Acrobat, are
there any? Feedback from faculty or students using Acrobat? A discussion of
problems encountered is at least as helpful to readers as the benefits of any
technique or technology, as users can be better prepared when trying the
suggestions for themselves.
Aside from the need for a little stylistic and typo editing, I feel this piece is well done and has merit but I would feel uncomfortable recommending its publication as it stands.
Critic II
The article, "Using PDF Files in the Classroom" offers useful advice for instructors unaware of the benefits of a method of displaying online documents that preserves the layout and design. The introduction should include a preview of the organization of the manuscript, that is, pointers to resources and examples, to benefits of PDF documents, to sample documents, tips on using PDF, and to PDF file creation, submission, downloading, and use. I wondered if it might not be a little introductory in content for the _Technology Source_ audience, but leave that judgment to the journal editor. Should alternative forms of document sharing (e.g., RTF files, text-only, HTML files, etc.) be presented upfront, with a brief explanation of how PDF files meet similar and alternative goals for file production and dissemination? Finally, I would recommend, since the authors have taken the time to list the numerous PDF resources available on the web, filling that list out by adding example items to each "genre" (e.g., manuals, newsletters, etc.). The manuscript would be a useful "Tools" contribution for instructors not familiar with Adobe Acrobat.